NCEAS Project 12320

When are matrix models useful for management? An empirical test across plant populations

  • Elizabeth E. Crone
  • Martha Ellis
  • Eric S. Menges

ActivityDatesFurther Information
Working Group13th—17th April 2009Participant List  
Working Group9th—13th November 2009Participant List  
Working Group27th February—3rd March 2010Participant List  
Working Group9th—13th November 2010Participant List  
Working Group9th—13th April 2011Participant List  

Abstract
In the past three decades, the role of matrix-based demographic models in plant conservation has steadily increased. However, the reliability of these methods remains hotly debated. Most tests of model performance have relied on strict conditions for either the datasets being tested or the criteria used to judge accuracy of the results. This leads to a potential disconnect between the variety of ways in which models are used in practice and the limited set of conditions where their performance has been evaluated. Our working group brings together a group of ecologists who have worked with these models in applied settings. We will review how models have actually been used in the recent past and discuss what predictions we expect these models to usefully provide. We will then use our demographic data from long-term studies to evaluate how well demographic models actually predict the dynamics of perennial plant populations. We will also address whether increasing methodological complexity (e.g. density dependence, integral projection modeling) improves reliability. The convergence of our group occurs at a moment when sufficient time and data have accumulated to test the predictions of demographic models at relevant time scales for management, and takes advantage of NCEAS capacities to bring together diverse groups and archive key data. Thus, this working group provides a timely opportunity to reevaluate what has become an exceptionally important tool in conservation and management.

TypeProducts of NCEAS Research
Data Set Crone, Elizabeth E. 2010. Literature review on the use of matrix population models for plants. (Online version)
Journal Article Crone, Elizabeth E.; Menges, Eric S.; Ellis, Martha; Bell, Timothy; Bierzychudek, Paulette; Ehrlén, Johan; Kaye, Thomas N.; Knight, Tiffany M.; Lesica, Peter; Morris, William F.; Oostermeijer, Gerard; Quintana-Ascencio, Pedro F.; Stanley, Amanda; Ticktin, Tamara; Valverde, Teresa; Williams, Jennifer L. 2011. How do plant ecologists use matrix population models?. Ecology Letters. Vol: 14. Pages 1-8.
Journal Article Pardini, Eleanor A.; Drake, John M.; Chase, Jonathan M.; Knight, Tiffany M. 2009. Complex population dynamics and control of the invasive biennial alliaria petiolata (garlic mustard). Ecological Applications. Vol: 19(2). Pages 387–397.